Register SignIn

PS3 Slim vs PS3 Phat

While Sony has refused to label its latest model of the Playstation 3 officially "Slim" as they did with the last PS2 model, a quick glance at the new hardware's specs and size will make you subconciously refer to the system as the PS3 Slim anyway. While it's not overly "slim" per say (it's roughly just as deep as the current PS3 model) it is considerably smaller in height and width, as well as weight at 1.5kg lighter.

The question has often been asked as to whether or not the new release PS3 is worth upgrading to. If you currently own a Playstation 3 console, chances are you've been remotely tempted at the very least to get your hands on the new hardware. But is it really worth the effort in trading in or selling your working console for a console that is essentially exactly the same, bar a few noticeable size differences?

The great thing about the PS3 design straight off the bat is its default colour. Black blends in with anything and everything, and while it's not totally out of the norm to see someone with a white or silver Playstation, black has without a doubt been the dominate flavour for PS2 and PS3 owners.

However, the PS3's appearance has not aged gracefully. Unlike the seemingly ageless design of the Wii and the just OK design of the XBOX 360, the Playstation 3 looks like a beast of a machine no matter how you have it standing. If you decide to lie it down flat, it looks as though you have a BBQ sitting underneath your television set. Set it up straight and you have a subwoofer that doubles as a games console and Blu-Ray player.

If this current design has anything going for it, it's that it looks substantially better than the original PS3 design. It's smoother, considerably lighter, and has the same comfortable design that the PS2 Slim had when it first came out. It's fair to say that the jump from PS3 Phat to the PS3 Slim is just as aggressive as the jump from the horrendously unattractive PS2 Phat to the PS2 Slim.

Sony has claimed that the new PS3 will be less 30 percent in size, length and height, with only the system's depth being slightly more than the current PS3 design. The specs of the current PS3 model have it at 12.82" wide, 10.79" deep and 3.86" tall. Compared to the newest PS3 model, you're looking at differences of roughly 1.40" in width, 1.30" in height and a considerable 1.5kg in weight.

PS3 Phat vs. PS3 Slim - The Size

PS3 PHAT PS3 SLIM
Width 12.81" 11.42"
Depth 10.79" 11.42"
Height 3.86 2.56
Weight 5 kg 3.5 kg

With a smaller machine also comes smaller specs, and while the overall performance of the console won't be overly compromised either way, there are some noteworthy changes to the guts of the PS3 with the latest model. Most notable is the decrease in power consumption compared to the latest PS3 model, with the earliest PS3 model back in 2006 consuming 380w compared to the PS3 Slim's 250w.

PS3 Phat vs. PS3 Slim - The Guts

PS3 PHAT PS3 SLIM
Processor 90nm (2006) / 65nm (2008) IBM Processor 45nm
Power consumption 380w / 280w 250w
Backwards compatibility PS2 Yes (20gb/60gb/80gb) PS1 Yes PS2 No PS1 Yes
HDD Capacity 20gb up to 160gb 120gb
Removable HDD Yes Yes

Selling at $499, the PS3 Slim won't be overly cheap, even when you consider its size compared to the original design. The contents inside the box are near identical for the two models - console, controller, cables etc. - although the lack of an ethernet cable in the PS3 Slim box is a bit of a letdown, even though the cable can be found lying around pretty much anywhere.

PS3 Phat vs. PS3 Slim - The Box

PS3 PHAT PS3 SLIM
Console Yes Yes
Controller Sixaxis (2006) / DualShock 3 (2008) DualShock 3
Cables Composite Composite
Ethernet Cable Yes No

Early PS3 owners got the pleasures of a console with multiple USB and Flash Card ports, as well as Wi-fi for access to the free PlaystationNetwork. As new versions of the hardware were released, we saw multiple differences, from a lack of wi-fi, to decreased USB ports, to no Flash Card reader whatsoever. With the PS3 Slim, we get a console with just about everything you'd need, with two USB ports and wi-fi.

PS3 Phat vs. PS3 Slim - The Connectivity

PS3 PHAT PS3 SLIM
Wi-fi Yes Yes
Flash Card Reader Yes (2006-2006) / No (2007 onwards) No
USB Ports 2-4 2

After having seen all of the above specs and comparison's between the two consoles, it's still difficult to say whether or not it's worth the upgrade. On one hand, you get the same console but smaller, with a far nicer overall appearance, with the console set to blend in with the surroundings much better than the beast of a console in the original PS3 design. On the other hand, you're going through the effort to either trade or sell your current working PS3 for essentially the same console. Furthermore, if you're not willing to sell or trade in and you want to know if it's worth it just to have, even as a second console, you've got to make a tough decision - is it really that much better to justify owning two of the same console, even though you really don't need a second console?

Overall, the new design looks sexy and with a considerably smaller design and just as many features as the current design, it's an obvious must-buy for current non-PS3 owners. For current PS3 owners, it depends on whether or not you're comfortable with the look of your current PS3.


The Playstation 3 will hit stores in Australia on September 3, 2009, for a RRP. of $499.95.

submit to digg

Tags: - beyond blu console game gameplay Gear Metal mgs4 over phat playstation Playstation2 Playstation3 ray slim Solid

8277 Views 42 Votes
Join MyPS3 to vote Add Comment
Gaetano 01/09/2009
Kudos: 10323  Mates: 118

Comments

hicksy93
Kudos: 2,336
cool, nice job
Formula 1 Championship Edition
Vinzor
Kudos: 13,127
I see the PS3 Slim and want to gouge my eyes out and die in a fire.
DJ Hero
jneffekt
Kudos: 1,516
amen to that vinzor
dan885154
Kudos: 457
Just to clarify the new PS3 does have the option to remove and upgrade the HDD.
QU1K51LV3R
Kudos: 8,040

dan885154 said: Just to clarify the new PS3 does have the option to remove and upgrade the HDD.


I thought it did.
Uncharted 2: Among Thieves
P3T3R
Kudos: 403
It seems pretty clear if you have a phat ps3 keep it if you dont have one at all get a slim.
LiLfiLo
Kudos: 2,899
It has PS1 backwards compatibilty but not ps2
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2
nickkcin
Kudos: 10,759
Fat kills the slim... cant even get a removable HDD on the slim...
Borderlands
Gaetano
Kudos: 10,323

nickkcin said: Fat kills the slim... cant even get a removable HDD on the slim...




Yeah you can.

au.ps3.ign.com/

2:31
Leisure Suit Larry: Box Office Bust
iaculch
Kudos: 4,024
Haha, so you can update the HDD, thats very cool. If you couldn't it would've been a real big let down.
FIFA 10
ZOIDBERG
Kudos: 2,607
The Slim also has Bitstream and Bravia Sync
Dumbnutz
Kudos: 1,570
Yeah the Slim is awesome the Bravia Sync is great (i own a Bravia Tv) personally i hated the shiny look of the phat combined with the silver trim thought it looked ugly and tacky i even prefer proper buttons for the eject and power switches so this is great for me im begining to find some real love for me PS3!

EDIT* Could someone post me a link to or tell me the best settings for PS3 so i can get the best out of bluray etc i think i know but just want to be sure, thanks
Coffey
Kudos: 347

QU1K51LV3R said:


dan885154 said: Just to clarify the new PS3 does have the option to remove and upgrade the HDD.


I thought it did.



reading that it didnt i was a little shocked and thought that i would never upgrade. once playtv comes out i will be needing space
Cryman
Kudos: 865
u can change the hdd in the slim model, why does your article state no
Grand Theft Auto IV
MITCHmAn4
Kudos: 185
*sniff* why no backward capability for PS2 games *sob*
DingooA320
Kudos: 6,201
SLIM FTW!!!

I went to the Swanston St, Melbourne City midnight launch...picked my Slim up for a discounted price, and was 99% happy (the 1% unsatisfactory feeling was due to the fact that the tiny PS logo on the console cannot be rotated to suit the vertical console stance positioning) with my purchase.

Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare
milo
Kudos: 816
just a thought with the whole no backward capability for PS2 thing, say if you want to , why cant they say have a game like v8supercars in the psn store, buy and download the full game and run it straight of the hard drive in ps3 format, but no disc needed? and still be able to paly on lan against ps2 players etc?
WWE SmackDown vs. Raw 2010
Gaetano
Kudos: 10,323

Cryman said: u can change the hdd in the slim model, why does your article state no




That's an error on my behalf. Fixed.
Leisure Suit Larry: Box Office Bust
nickkcin
Kudos: 10,759

Gaetano said:


nickkcin said: Fat kills the slim... cant even get a removable HDD on the slim...


Yeah you can.
au.ps3.ign.com/
2:31

sorry, its just what was written. its all right now, you've fixed it
Borderlands
Eedgy1
Kudos: 3,885
Come read my reveiw on the PS3 slim!
MyPS3 Miscellaneous
raybert
Kudos: 16,155

Eedgy1 said: Come read my reveiw on the PS3 slim!


Nice...

I'm thinking about upgrading.

Cause I can trade in my old PS3 and some cash for it @ EB
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2
SU8TLE
Kudos: 1,826
for the price difference of selling my phatty and buying a slim.
id rather slot a nice 500GB hDD in my phatty.
Warhammer 40,000
Eedgy1
Kudos: 3,885
SLIM FOR LIFE!

...

or until something new comes out...
MyPS3 Miscellaneous
jsutton001
Kudos: 129
Not bothering to buy a slim. I'm happy with my phat.
declan8
Kudos: 1,851
the slim looks crappy.
the plastic is matte and rough.
the font on the console is not as good
when viewing it from the top it looks like a square which looks retarded
it has buttons instead of touch to tun on and eject
Fallout 3
timebomb
Kudos: 4
Hi I just bought the slim and I have the Jabra I bought last year with warhawk and I can't seem to get it to register, what do I do cause you need a mic to play online..
ilikeike
Kudos: 139
Slim is sexy!!
Battlefield 1943
timebomb
Kudos: 4
both of them play video games, movies and music, who cares what the thing looks like...they are both sweet and for those who can't afford the Phatt then its a good price for the slim...its also less bulky and takes up less room...which is good when you live in a poop hole apartment and don't have a lot of space
nothing07
Kudos: 2,772

declan8 said: the slim looks crappy.
the plastic is matte and rough.
the font on the console is not as good
when viewing it from the top it looks like a square which looks retarded
it has buttons instead of touch to tun on and eject


Yep i agree.

Slim looks ugly as ****.
But thats just my opinion.
MAG
Jimbo_1993
Kudos: 11,070
since when did the phat ps3 come with an ethernet cable
Guitar Hero Metallica
Megaaidan
Kudos: 728
both phat and slim look great, but the PS3 phats are being discontinued
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2
junkrunner
Kudos: 219
Will ps3 "slims" perform better then ps3 phat?
EggBeater-
Kudos: 835

junkrunner said: Will ps3 "slims" perform better then ps3 phat?



It performs exactly the same.
Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots
mat
Kudos: 400
phat hands down ftw
California Games
kormac
Kudos: 797
Slim looks kool.. But phat for life.. Gotta love ps2 compatibility And also I want my splash screen back when i start ps3 games. Miss my "ding" sound. The slim robbed me of this!
Killzone 2
dans
Kudos: 1,952
phat
FIFA 10
dummo_11
Kudos: 171
I can only afford Slim lol...
its **** about how theirs no backward capability for PS2 games...
cos i have a **** load of ps2 games are still worth a play once in a while....
Jacko360
Kudos: 147
Nice, but Phat for me thanx.
Borderlands
damex95
Kudos: 1,142
It's not about whats on the outside, but whats on the inside
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2
 
To participate in this discussion, please log in or register.
MyPS3 User

PS3 Games

MyPS3 Features

Bad Company 2 Vs. M.A.G
Poll 01/02/2010 76 36
BioShock 2 Bargain Wrap-Up
News 9 hours 18 5
M.A.G with PS3 Headset $98
News 20 hours 5 16
5 reasons to love MAG
Guide 4 days 0 7
Is there room for the iPad?
Blog 28/01/2010 44 19
Dark Void Review
Review 28/01/2010 1 3
Bayonetta Review
Review 20/01/2010 8 23
Bioshock 2 Preview
Guide 18/01/2010 2 0
Bioshock 2 Interview
Guide 15/01/2010 4 3
Playstation 3 - Games of 2010
Guide 12/01/2010 9 18
Dragon Ball: Raging Blast FAQ
Cheat 03/12/2009 0 1
G.I JOE: Rise of Cobra FAQ
Cheat 30/11/2009 2 0
Uncharted 2: Among Thieves FAQ
Cheat 10/11/2009 2 2
Marvel Ultimate Alliance 2 FAQ
Cheat 03/11/2009 0 0
Ninja Gaiden Sigma 2 FAQ
Cheat 28/10/2009 1 1

PS3 Discussions

MasterMira 3 mins
Ramzez 4 mins
MasterMira 6 mins
standinsid 12 mins
MicDaMan 13 mins
rivalZone 18 mins
MicDaMan 18 mins
furransu 29 mins
RatedY2J 34 mins
Speedoponi 38 mins

PS3 Videos

PS3 Photos

  • The tower
    15 13
  • updated spiranovic's $150 psn comp entry
    5 12
  • Final Fantasy XIII Lightning's weapon Blaze Edge
    5 5
  • M/V Athena
    6 5
  • My F1 Car
    0 4
  • ArNoLDo's Entry For vyma Competition
    2 3

Favourite PS3 Games

MyPS3 Lists

Good PS3 Ports/Versions
Dumbnutz 31/01/2010 3 6
Top 5 PS2 Games of All Time
RatedY2J 29/01/2010 12 5
MY Most anticipated game of 2010
LeGaCy88 27/01/2010 3 4
My Most Anticipated PS3 Games of 2010
teknikal 27/01/2010 2 3

PS3 Games Out This Month

Dante's Inferno
04 February 2010 3
BioShock 2
09 February 2010 9
MAG
11 February 2010 25
Heavy Rain
26 February 2010 45

Recent Comments

Status Updates

Mik3y now has pwnage at two different places :p
Mik3y pennywise kowaii desu ne!! D:
jason_rhcp was granted Bioshock 2 Medal medal
jason_rhcp was granted Bioshock 2 Medal- 2 medal
Ramzez What cap? Do you have an issue with me? -_-