I thought about how I'd rate the games that I still own and the ones that I owned at some point in time and decided that I'd have to rate them based on a mix of enjoyment that I got from playing them, time I spent playing them in relation to each other and whether I eventually started hating a particular quirk/feature of the game. This has also made me reflect on some of my terrible choices. Here they are:
COD4: 8/10
RSV2: 9/10
RSV: 6/10
Heavenly Sword: 6/10
Rachet&Clank: 7/10
AC: 3/10
Pro Evo 2008: 6/10
FIFA 07: 6/10
FIFA 08: 7/10
NHL 08: 8/10
NBA Live 08: 5/10
NBA 2k8: 7/10
College Hoops 2k8: 9/10
Orange Box: 6/10
Kane & Lynch: 6/10
UT3: 9/10
GH3: 7/10
Uncharted: 8/10
DIRT: 7/10
Warhawk: 4/10
Army of Two: 5/10
NFS Carbon: 4/10
Burnout Paradise: 6/10
RFOM: 6/10
Ninja Gaiden Sigma: 6/10
Conflict Denied Ops: 3/10
No 10/10 from me because that's like a holly grail of gaming for me, and everything has to appeal - from truly amazing graphics to flawless gameplay without annoying quirks that sooner or later give you the ****s. In other words, to have NO COMPLAINTS whatsoever about a game.