Register SignIn

Assassin’s Creed 2 Review

Don't you recognize me? It's-a me, Mario!

By Ben Salter

If Assassin’s Creed 2 has taught us one thing, it’s that games can be based on historic events besides world war II, and be successful. The second Assassin’s Creed is a mixture of historically accurate people and places, and a fictional narrative. More importantly Assassin’s Creed 2 is a much better game than its predecessor. The first game was by no means bad, but it was establishing a new, hopefully very successful, IP. Ubisoft have taken what they learnt from the first game, improved it in almost every aspect and crafted a rather compelling action/adventure game.

The way that the plot evolves after the prologue in Assassin’s Creed 2 is fantastic. Unfortunately the opening doesn’t quite live up to the rest of the narrative; it’s a shame, and I really hope it doesn’t deter anyone from playing further. You begin as Desmond Miles, as an assistant named Lucy is breaking him out of a high-tech lab. The story behind this is rather complex, but it’s told in a fairly boring manner and it’s hard to follow if you have no prior information about the game.

Lucy and her gang of underground workers strap Desmond to the Animus machine, where he is able to relive the memories of his ancestor, Ezio Auditore, who lived in Florence during the 15th century. Most of the game is played as Ezio, as we follow his rise as an Assassin against the Templars. Meanwhile Ezio’s DNA is being synched with Desmond in the Animus. This is where the story really starts to captivate the audience - the story of Ezio Auditore. The locations, some situations and people are based on historical facts. If you know your 15th century Templar Knights you might find yourself predicting who will come up next in the lengthy adventure – spanning over 20 hours. If you don’t, it doesn’t really matter, as the story itself is fictional. Ubisoft does a great job of leaving the player on the edge of their seat, so to speak, at the end of each mission and sequence. It becomes one of those games that you can’t put down. You keep telling yourself “just one more mission” at the end of the gaming day, but the more you play it, the harder it is to stop.

If you don’t care about an engaging story, the action is just as good. Assassin’s Creed has a distinct Prince of Persia feel about it, and that’s by no means a bad thing. You’ll spend a lot of your time scaling walls, climbing roof tops, and jumping between ledges, just as the good Prince has done so many times. The climbing controls are quite basic, as essentially you run into a wall, or to a ledge, and Ezio will either climb it or jump. The simple nature of the controls keeps everything fast paced, just as it needs to be for an assassin running above the city.

Ezio is also a much better assassin than his processor, Altair. While he had some cool moves Altair never really used them to his advantage. That’s where Ezio comes in. His two hidden blades, for example, can (and need to) be used for quick and silent assassinations on two targets simultaneously. If stealth goes out the window Ezio’s trusty sword, along with a range of other weapons, come into play. Using a lock-on combat system you either aggressively attack, or hold back and wait to dodge or counter. The latter is by far the most effective tactic, as the polite guards generally only attack one at a time, at least in the early stages. For this reason running in swords blazing does tend to get a bit tiresome. Finding ways to avoid hordes of enemies, and mastering silent takedowns are much more rewarding, when possible.

The complex dual combat system works once you’ve mastered it, but to be honest it’s more confusing than it had to be. The climbing and running (platforming) controls are so simple and fluid that they feel like more of a racing game. Combat, on the other hand, feels more like a confusing RTS. Once you know what you’re doing it’s fine, but it’s a lengthy process. You have to lock on to an enemy with one trigger, and it’s often not the enemy you wanted to target, and then either attack with the face buttons or hold down the right trigger to use defensive commands instead. With time you get used to this, but Ezio takes a beating while you're still learning. It turns into a button mashing fest, rather than well thought out strategies, when enemies surround you. It’s not bad; it’s just a little over complicated, and nowhere near as fun as the more stylish assassinations.

Assassin’s Creed 2 addresses a major flaw from the first Creed by including a range of different missions. The main story has you running across the vast open world to the next memory icons, and has a very 15th century GTA meets Zelda feel to it. As well as these there’s a range of things to do outside of the main story. So much, in fact, that it’s almost impossible not to get sidetracked at some point. You can earn money to spend on whatever takes your fancy, including rebuilding your hometown of Monteriggioni. Once uncle Mario (and the Super Mario Bros references are great) introduces you to your heritage most of Ezio’s non-compulsory activities are monitored at his villa. This includes collecting feathers and statues, while finding viewpoints will open up more of the world and increase what you can discover. In total there are six assassin tombs to uncover, which act as dungeons full of puzzles to conquer and guards to avoid (although why all these tombs are filled with guards we don’t know). These provide some nice linear platforming levels, as generally there is more than one way to go about things in the main story missions.

The different tactical options allow everyone to play to their strengths. While moving throughout the city you can, like me, choose the faster, but most dangerous, route and run across the rooftops, risking being spotted by guards and having your notoriety levels rise. If that doesn’t tickle your fancy you can hire a group of prostitutes to tempt guards in your path, or walk slowly and try to blend in with the crowds. There’s a range of different, and rather cool ways to assassinate people, but there’s an equal number of ways to move around to get yourself in that perfect position to make your move.

The new notoriety meter measures how likely the guards are to attack you, based on recent actions. As you kill and steal the meter fills. When you have a full meter guards will immediately suspect and attack you. When it’s empty most of the time you can walk right past without raising suspicion. This is combined with an action meter above the guards’ heads. As it fills with orange they become more curious as to what you’re up to, this will happen when you’re seen being socially unacceptable - like climbing rooftops; turning red indicates that they'll attack. When being pursued by the law Ezio can hide in safe zones, such as bails of hay, as long as he’s not seen entering them. Or he can try and blend in with the crowd. It’s a very realistic portrayal of stealth, as it goes beyond the traditional set-up of being hidden if you’re out of the enemy’s line of sight. Of course, you can always choose to stand your ground and fight when being chased. At first there’s normally only two guards, so if you’re fast enough Ezio can take them down before reinforcements arrive.

Assassin’s Creed 2 is set in 15th century Italy, and the cities look fantastic. The vibrant countrysides, the artistic flair and an array of tones immerse the player into the gaming world. Quite frankly the world is stunning - fitting considering the historical context behind the game’s setting. The voice acting is great, and really helps to absorb the player into the stunning cities of Florence and Venice. The environmental sound effects are also right on the money, as is the background music which is there when it needs to be.

The Final Verdict

Assassin’s Creed 2 is an improvement on its predecessor in almost every way. The story, which starts slow, becomes very engaging and evolves almost perfectly for a videogame. The action/adventure gameplay has the right mix of platforming elements, side quests, assassinations and general combat. Best of all, every one of these things can be done in numerous different ways, leaving the tactics down to the individual player. Assassin’s Creed 2 looks and sounds great, and really immerses the player into 15th century Italy. It’s a great step forward for the series, one of the more mature games out there that uses strong platforming elements, and leaves you wanting more at the end of each mission. This is how to create a sequel for a new IP.

Gamplay

9.0/10

Great adventure gameplay, and assassinations. The tactical variety is also fantastic and the story will leave you wanting more.

Graphics

9.2/10

Stunning world, full of detail and life.

Sound

9.0/10

Great voice-overs and sound effects.

Value

9.2/10

There’s easily 20+ hours of gameplay here, possibly a lot more if you get stuck into all of the side quests.

Overall

9.1/10

submit to digg

3516 Views 17 Votes
Join MyPS3 to vote Add Comment
ICC_06 25/11/2009
Kudos: 4800  Mates: 51
 

Assassin's Creed 2 - Full MyPS3 Game Profile

Assassin's Creed 2 News

Ezio to star in Assassin's Creed 3
Gaetano 15/01/2010 10 Comments 9 Votes
Assassin's Creed 2 DLC details and pricing
Gaetano 17/12/2009 14 Comments 58 Votes
Assassin's Creed 2 DLC announced
Gaetano 02/12/2009 14 Comments 7 Votes

Assassin's Creed 2 Discussions

[GD] Assassin's Creed 2
tiberius 37 mins 1,007 Posts 23,848 Views
Assassin's Creed Multiplayer!!!
vivaladil 14/01/2010 18 Posts 195 Views
Assassin's Creed 2 Spoilers Thread
mickyt888 06/01/2010 38 Posts 729 Views

Assassin's Creed 2 Guides

Playstation 3 Christmas 2009 Buying Guide
Gaetano 01/12/2009 14 Comments 26 Votes

Assassin's Creed 2 Reviews

Assassin’s Creed 2 Review - 9.1/10
ICC_06 25/11/2009 21 Comments 17 Votes

Assassin's Creed 2 Videos

Comments

kusherl
Kudos: 711
Mates: 17
My wife has told me "NOT" to buy this as my birthday is next Thursday so I've got a feeling I'm going to be very happy on my birthday. Can't wait to play...

Great review ICC_06
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2
RatedY2J
Kudos: 10,737
Mates: 218
Personally i would give it a 9.3/10 but otherwise great review
Uncharted 2: Among Thieves
kiZZer
Kudos: 410
Mates: 44
yeh realli good review ICC_09, heres a lol
Assassin's Creed 2
Morgan1219
Kudos: 9,335
Mates: 179
Good review but it deserves a 9.8/10 but each to their own

I rate your review
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2
Tsunamo
Kudos: 949
Mates: 26
Nice review, Ben. I loved the Mario reference that Ubisoft put in the game.
LittleBigPlanet
chrisco84
Kudos: 2,293
Mates: 22

Morgan1219 said: Good review but it deserves a 9.8/10 but each to their own


While this is a solid game it is NOT a 9.8 game, no way. 9.1 max.
There is way to much screen tear and pop in, the game freezes and there are frame rate issues, i know they are not deal breakers but if you are rating a game so high i can only imagine you are ignoring these blatant problems.
I would personally give this game a 9. it has a great story, incredible gameplay but is let down from some technical faults, that i beleive should have been picked up in testing.
Battlefield: Bad Company
ICC_06
Kudos: 4,800
Mates: 51

chrisco84 said:

Morgan1219 said: Good review but it deserves a 9.8/10 but each to their own


While this is a solid game it is NOT a 9.8 game, no way. 9.1 max.
There is way to much screen tear and pop in, the game freezes and there are frame rate issues, i know they are not deal breakers but if you are rating a game so high i can only imagine you are ignoring these blatant problems.
I would personally give this game a 9. it has a great story, incredible gameplay but is let down from some technical faults, that i beleive should have been picked up in testing.



Screen tear isn't present in the 360 version (which we played). Also experienced no frame rate or freezing issues. Still, the combats good, but not perfect.
Resident Evil 5
chrisco84
Kudos: 2,293
Mates: 22

ICC_06 said:


chrisco84 said:


Morgan1219 said: Good review but it deserves a 9.8/10 but each to their own


While this is a solid game it is NOT a 9.8 game, no way. 9.1 max.
There is way to much screen tear and pop in, the game freezes and there are frame rate issues, i know they are not deal breakers but if you are rating a game so high i can only imagine you are ignoring these blatant problems.
I would personally give this game a 9. it has a great story, incredible gameplay but is let down from some technical faults, that i beleive should have been picked up in testing.


Screen tear isn't present in the 360 version (which we played). Also experienced no frame rate or freezing issues. Still, the combats good, but not perfect.


In now way am i attacking your review its great, i was just stating mainly to Morgan that its not a 9.8 game.
Screen tear is present on the PS3 version (which i played) and i and many other have experienced frame rate and freezing issues.
Battlefield: Bad Company
Pantera90
Kudos: 1,912
Mates: 41

chrisco84 said:

ICC_06 said:


chrisco84 said:


Morgan1219 said: Good review but it deserves a 9.8/10 but each to their own


While this is a solid game it is NOT a 9.8 game, no way. 9.1 max.
There is way to much screen tear and pop in, the game freezes and there are frame rate issues, i know they are not deal breakers but if you are rating a game so high i can only imagine you are ignoring these blatant problems.
I would personally give this game a 9. it has a great story, incredible gameplay but is let down from some technical faults, that i beleive should have been picked up in testing.


Screen tear isn't present in the 360 version (which we played). Also experienced no frame rate or freezing issues. Still, the combats good, but not perfect.


In now way am i attacking your review its great, i was just stating mainly to Morgan that its not a 9.8 game.
Screen tear is present on the PS3 version (which i played) and i and many other have experienced frame rate and freezing issues.

or maybe nobody here takes care of their PS3's, making games go screwy
Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots
Megaaidan
Kudos: 708
Mates: 10
^^ Who knows, but i didnt like the look of AC2, might give it a try
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2
chrisco84
Kudos: 2,293
Mates: 22

Pantera90 said:


chrisco84 said:


ICC_06 said:


chrisco84 said:


Morgan1219 said: Good review but it deserves a 9.8/10 but each to their own


While this is a solid game it is NOT a 9.8 game, no way. 9.1 max.
There is way to much screen tear and pop in, the game freezes and there are frame rate issues, i know they are not deal breakers but if you are rating a game so high i can only imagine you are ignoring these blatant problems.
I would personally give this game a 9. it has a great story, incredible gameplay but is let down from some technical faults, that i beleive should have been picked up in testing.


Screen tear isn't present in the 360 version (which we played). Also experienced no frame rate or freezing issues. Still, the combats good, but not perfect.


In now way am i attacking your review its great, i was just stating mainly to Morgan that its not a 9.8 game.
Screen tear is present on the PS3 version (which i played) and i and many other have experienced frame rate and freezing issues.

or maybe nobody here takes care of their PS3's, making games go screwy


Far out guys, i apologise for critizising the game. My ps3 is very well looked after along with the rest of my entertainment centre.
Battlefield: Bad Company
Morgan1219
Kudos: 9,335
Mates: 179
@Chrisco - My game ran smooth as a babies butt and only froze once. There were no issues whatsoever. Obviously you didnt read my first comment properly because i said that i think it deserves a 9.8/10 but each to their own
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2
chrisco84
Kudos: 2,293
Mates: 22

Morgan1219 said: @Chrisco - My game ran smooth as a babies butt and only froze once. There were no issues whatsoever. Obviously you didnt read my first comment properly because i said that i think it deserves a 9.8/10 but each to their own


I respect your opinion, thats sweet im just stating there are issues with this game and now im a damn villian.
BTW that face thing really annoys me.
Battlefield: Bad Company
ICC_06
Kudos: 4,800
Mates: 51
Valid points mate. I was just saying we didn't have those problems on 360, but I have heard they do exist on PS3. Unfortunately we only got a 360 copy to review, so could not compare it (but normally there's no need for us to be sent a copy on both platforms).
Resident Evil 5
DPkrass
Kudos: 191
Mates: 7
no mention of being boring and repetitive like the 1st one? i take it ,its not? I liked the 1st one and not often ill bin the game before i finish it (if i like it) so it must have been very repetitive. One thing that makes me aprehensive in buying this .Might wait for more reviews.
Grand Theft Auto IV
Jacko360
Kudos: 141
Mates: 8
All my cousins and friends have it.
They never stop telling me how good it is. Making me jealous
Borderlands
byrnezy
Kudos: 701
Mates: 18
Amazing game... not aware of any tear issues thus far and it hasnt frozen or anything yet either and i have it on the ps3.. id say 9.4/10 for sure
Uncharted 2: Among Thieves
Aeschylus
Kudos: 1,249
Mates: 18
It's been awhile where a sequel has come out and been a vast improvement.

AC2 is a totally different game, instead of the prolonged same old missions they have mixed it up so instead of running from 1 rooftop to another or just killing some old guy there are now more weapons, more missions, different ways of finishing missions, help from thieves/harlots ect..
Fallout 3
Aeschylus
Kudos: 1,249
Mates: 18
Loved the Mario Reference to "It's me Mario"
It's me Ezio.
Fallout 3
bcb
Kudos: 1,776
Mates: 22

Aeschylus said: Loved the Mario Reference to "It's me Mario"
It's me Ezio.


that was lmao funny
Resistance 2
ACID45
Kudos: 110
Mates: 3
hooray 4 da Vinci and his murder weapons
Tekken 6
 
To participate in this discussion, please log in or register.
MyPS3 User

PS3 Games

MyPS3 Features

Bad Company 2 Vs. M.A.G
Poll 3 days 50 28
EB Games R18+ Petition
News 13 hours 7 18
SEGA wants more Shenmue
News 2 days 14 4
Is there room for the iPad?
Blog 28/01/2010 42 18
Dark Void Review
Review 28/01/2010 1 3
Happy Australia Day!
Blog 26/01/2010 31 5
Bayonetta Review
Review 20/01/2010 8 23
Bioshock 2 Preview
Guide 18/01/2010 2 0
Bioshock 2 Interview
Guide 15/01/2010 4 3
Playstation 3 - Games of 2010
Guide 12/01/2010 9 18
Darksiders Review
Review 05/01/2010 14 18
Playstation 3 - Best of 2009
Guide 16/12/2009 11 11
Red Dead Redemption Preview #2
Guide 16/12/2009 4 11
Dragon Ball: Raging Blast FAQ
Cheat 03/12/2009 0 1
G.I JOE: Rise of Cobra FAQ
Cheat 30/11/2009 2 0
Uncharted 2: Among Thieves FAQ
Cheat 10/11/2009 2 2
Marvel Ultimate Alliance 2 FAQ
Cheat 03/11/2009 0 0
Ninja Gaiden Sigma 2 FAQ
Cheat 28/10/2009 1 1

PS3 Discussions

PS3 Videos

PS3 Photos

  • updated spiranovic's $150 psn comp entry
    4 9
  • The tower
    6 8
  • My ps3 collection 25/1/10
    2 6
  • FFXIII Meets Transformers Arts Figures
    2 6
  • My F1 Car
    0 4
  • Comp entry
    1 3

Favourite PS3 Games

MyPS3 Lists

Top 5 MP Games on PS3
RatedY2J 22/01/2010 14 6
Good PS3 Ports/Versions
Dumbnutz 5 days 2 6
Top 5 PS2 Games of All Time
RatedY2J 6 days 11 5
MY Most anticipated game of 2010
LeGaCy88 27/01/2010 1 4
My Most Anticipated PS3 Games of 2010
teknikal 27/01/2010 2 3

PS3 Games Out This Month

Dante's Inferno
04 February 2010 3
BioShock 2
09 February 2010 9
Aliens vs Predator
18 February 2010 6
Heavy Rain
26 February 2010 45

Recent Comments

Status Updates

Emjay57 added a new photo - Bad Company 2
skua Only been around here 990 days :) I have higher days over at mywii and mypsp :)
Bones Finally made it to 1000 days old on site. 1005 to be exact.
Fazbot wrote a news article - Project Needlemouse = Sonic 4