Best Australian PlayStation 3 Community, News, Games, Videos, Competitions, and Forums. DMC 4, MGS 4, Grand Theft Auto IV, Devil May Cry 4, Metal Gear Solid 4, Silent Hill 5, Call of Duty 4, Gran Turismo 5, COD4, and More!

Playstation 3 Software & Firmware \ 2 months later, is GTAIV a 9.9/10 in your book?

1 2 Next »

Kudos: 3,590

Mates: 63

That was my score for it www.myps3.com.au/ and obviously you all have conflicting opinions it, but after MGS4 and a few other great titles, do you still think it's so good? I mean, games evolve and perceptions change over time, so do you still think it's as unique and amazing as it was 2 months ago when it was released?

01/07/2008

Melbourne

Kudos: 13,879

Mates: 149

K-Man says:

Hmmm... i went from a 10 to a 9.8 and now a 8.5. That double XP weekend from COD4 a few weeks back got me hooked on it again so i lost my attention on GTAIV. I'll lose a lot more attention on GTAIV once i get MGS4.

01/07/2008

California, U.S | MyPS3, MyWii, MyDS

Kudos: 13,163

Mates: 899

gdmatt says:

Yes, it is still an incredible game. I love MGS4, but I prefer GTA IV.

01/07/2008

Melbourne, Victoria

Kudos: 2,159

Mates: 63

heller says:

I stopped playing it about three weeks after getting it, just like every other gta game in the series, good for a while quickly becomes boring

01/07/2008

Melbourne, Vic

Kudos: 156

Mates: 2

exitmusic says:

I've had it for 4 or 5 weeks now and haven't got close to finishing it yet, I lost interest in the storyline half way through and found the missions to repetitive. I got a few other games around the same time that have kept me from going back to it. Prob around a 7 out of 10 all up from me, fun in patches but repetitive and predictable.

01/07/2008

Melbourne

Kudos: 3,888

Mates: 64

Unhostile says:

heller said: I stopped playing it about three weeks after getting it, just like every other gta game in the series, good for a while quickly becomes boring

I sadly have to agree with him..
i finished it and now i am kinda over it..
i will probably get back to it but not too soon

01/07/2008

Sydney, NSW, PSN ID: HostileForLife

Kudos: 966

Mates: 47

RSOP says:

Have to agree to, stoped playing the missions long ago. 7/10

01/07/2008

Melbourne

Kudos: 1,449

Mates: 38

reags says:

funny how being caught up with hype increases everything's value. its good people are finally seeing it objectively since the hype is over.

01/07/2008

Outside your window, behind those trees..

Kudos: 2,561

Mates: 28

SpaceSteve says:

I would never have scored it so high in the first place. It is a great looking game, has some interesting new features, but its what isnt included that disapointed me. Houses with garages and heliports, the ability to fly planes, buying property, a casino all of the cool stuff that was in previous games was sadly lacking from this one.

01/07/2008

Aussie Aussie Aussie Oy Oy Oy

Kudos: 9,771

Mates: 139

Smajs says:

I still haven't finished it x_x so yeah i'd still give it a 9er

01/07/2008

Kudos: 3,888

Mates: 64

Unhostile says:

SpaceSteve said: I would never have scored it so high in the first place. It is a great looking game, has some interesting new features, but its what isnt included that disapointed me. Houses with garages and heliports, the ability to fly planes, buying property, a casino all of the cool stuff that was in previous games was sadly lacking from this one.

i agree

01/07/2008

Sydney, NSW, PSN ID: HostileForLife

Kudos: 4,214

Mates: 659

jason_rhcp says:

when i first got it i thought it was worthy of a 10 but not i think its more of a 9

01/07/2008

Adelaide, South Australia

Kudos: 26,024

Mates: 478

callan5 says:

Definitely still a 10/10 game imo, im still finding new things happening even now.What makes it any different to what it was 2 months ago? Its not like they remove features each day. I do agree to an extent that perhaps MGS4 kinda stamped on its parade abit, but i only judge GTA IV for what it is, i dont compare it to anything else really, hence why i probably still find it one of the best games around.

01/07/2008

Outside Perth W.A countryside, over those green mountains

Kudos: 1,307

Mates: 41

Kjt15 says:

i never even finished the missions. Got too bored. MGS4 is the new 10/10!

01/07/2008

QLD

Kudos: 445

Mates: 13

foxhound1 says:

i have jumped ship to MGS4 & MGO for now. When i finish MGS4 i will come back and finish GTA4. I agree that too many things were left out e.g. gambling, jet pack, property assets.

01/07/2008

brisbane

Kudos: 88

Mates: 5

Hardcorexx says:

No i reckon an 8-10

01/07/2008

Melbs

Kudos: 1,451

Mates: 53

lukeclem1 says:

i gave it a 9 when it first come out n i still reckon its a 9
but i havent played mgs4 yet

01/07/2008

Liberty City

Kudos: 134

Mates: 7

Maniaman says:

nope, i stopped playing AGES ago, probably should sell it.

01/07/2008

Brisbane

Kudos: 631

Mates: 13

fd3s says:

i think its about 7.5 / 10 but my gf still loves it

01/07/2008

Melbourne

Kudos: 1,908

Mates: 20

Jeffie says:

there are too many flaws for how high a score its received everywhere.

id say 7-8. huge part that drags the score down is the driving to lengthen missions, and how repetitive the missions are... plus all the normal flaws that you would expect to be ironed out of most games.

01/07/2008

http://www.play-asia.com/SOap-23-83-8k80.html

Kudos: 1,246

Mates: 21

IKTPQ says:

lol i was only thinking of making the same thread at work 2day. i would of given it 7/10 to start with and would still give it that much. i hardly even play it anymore

01/07/2008

Tasmania

Kudos: 1,389

Mates: 40

topher says:

i always said that this game wasnt worthy of a 10. i give it a 7 at most

01/07/2008

PSN = chris300zx

Kudos: 416

Mates: 8

acid says:

exitmusic said: I've had it for 4 or 5 weeks now and haven't got close to finishing it yet, I lost interest in the storyline half way through and found the missions to repetitive. I got a few other games around the same time that have kept me from going back to it. Prob around a 7 out of 10 all up from me, fun in patches but repetitive and predictable.

I have a very similar view, except i did finish it hoping the missions would start to improve in their creativity and comedic charm. Unfortunately they never did, graphically gta4 is an impressive achievement but the gameplay has gone backwards.

Instead of tanks, car customization, owning businesses, planes, massive playing field and hilarious missions. We get spam, constant whining cell calls, annoying accents, crap music, boring missions, basically a game that forgot its own heritage and while trying to come across as "refined and sophisticated" ends up being pretentious and over confident.

Thankfully the uncut version only cost me $68 delivered to my door.

01/07/2008

KONAMI ID: @c!d

Kudos: 3,888

Mates: 64

Unhostile says:

I wish they brought tanks back in..
i want to get a tank and drive over a car.. imagine seeing the car just getting squished.. instead of it blowing up as soon as you touch it

01/07/2008

Sydney, NSW, PSN ID: HostileForLife

Kudos: 12,994

Mates: 171

skua says:

well, id say that GTA is definately not still number 10 for me, because of several things. one of the main reasons is the story line is so repetitive, all you do is go arouund like a hitman and kill kill kill. yes , the online is good,,but im not sure. i'd say, from 10/10 to 8/10

01/07/2008

Bad Company Owns!!!!! PSN_ID: lnknpk

1 2 newer »

To participate in this discussion, please log in or register.

MyPS3 Says:

PS3 Polls

Has The Inclusion Of Trophies Changed The Way You Are Playing A Game? 34

PS3 Games

NBA Live 09
Bourne Conspiracy, The
Need for Speed ProStreet
LittleBigPlanet

PS3 News

Games that will be shown at the Leipzig Gaming Convention

55 18 163 9 hours ago

New Force Unleashed Videos + Screenshots

58 4 100 10 hours ago

Sony Announces Music Peripheral Cross Game Compatibility

62 13 217 18 hours ago

eGames 2008, Meet iDEF!

70 4 90 20 hours ago

EA Sports Announces FIFA 09 Soundtrack

5 1 45 1 days ago

PS3 Videos

F.E.A.R Trailer
Beijing 2008 - Swimming Gameplay
The Bourne Conspiracy Trailer
CES 2008: Logitech's tiny Bluetooth keyboard for PCs & PS3s

PS3 Photos

9 17
5 14
1 8
2 8
4 8
6 8

MyPS3 Lists

SONY - My SONY PS3 Blu-ray Disc games

3 1 19 7 hours ago

my top 5 fave games

6 5 153 6 days ago

MyPS3's First 30 Members

15 8 156 12/08/2008

My Top 10 PSN Games

8 6 198 10/08/2008

Games i have been addicted to so far....

12 3 186 09/08/2008

MyPS3 Blogs

MyBluRay Movie Trivia III: The Return of Medals (Win a Blu-Ray disc of your choice!)

21 0 1 days ago

Comic #2.09 - 'Nerd Rage'

30 1 5 days ago

Things to do to prepare your self for Street fighter 4

44 9 6 days ago

Comics: A slight delay...

41 0 6 days ago

PSWii60 - Episode 1: The Beginning of the End

61 4 09/08/2008

Comments

Command and Conquer: Red Alert 3	vryan15	2 hours ago
Darkness, The	cbr929rr	2 hours ago
MyPS3 Folding@home breaks 1.5mil!	jebusman	4 hours ago
FFXIII demo details. NO 1	mickyt888	5 hours ago
Sega Know Sonic Needs a Revival	port3s	5 hours ago
MyPS3 Folding@home breaks 1.5mil!	port3s	5 hours ago
Games that will be shown at the Leipzig Gaming Convention	robo3687	5 hours ago
FFXIII demo details. NO 1	geno	5 hours ago
(REMOVED)	nickthe	6 hours ago
New Force Unleashed Videos + Screenshots	Noobito	6 hours ago

Everyone is...

Dark_Angel: "I believe whatever doesn't kill you simply makes you...stranger!"

MY07GT: Obsessed with buying games!

smshun: from Hong Kong. I played TV games for 20 years. I sell mainly Japan or Asian version games on different platforms worldwide. Send me PM or email if you want a quote, you'd be satisfy with my service!

nickthe: wants siren blood curse soo badly

zyxses: About to play Uncharted.

Send us news tips!