Register SignIn

Rock Band Review

Rock Band Review

A Review - By Steve Heller

It seems a million years ago that a little developer named Harmonix teamed up with Red Octane to bring the world Guitar Hero. Harmonix has since sold the rights to that franchise and moved on to bigger and better things. A year ago in the USA Rock Band was the first, and only full band experience you could get on your consoles, but that was a year ago. Now the game has finally landed on Australian shores, does it compete with its rival Guitar Hero World Tour? Does Rock Band bring enough rock to the stage?

Rock Band offers a full band experience, based on fun and music more-so than competition. This works in the games favor as it gives it a feel of it's own, something that separates itself from World Tour. It features your standard Quickplay mode, and of course Xbox Live battles, but for most of us who get sucked into this game, you will be spending most of your time in the World Tour Mode.

World Tour Mode places you on a map featuring a bunch of cities across the globe (Sydney is in there!) with each city having a series of venues. As you play gigs you will earn cash, get fans and unlock competitions for you to compete at. The non-linear approach to the series gives it a sense of freedom, rather than just playing through a list of tracks and unlocking more, it makes you feel like you are achieving something with your music. As you move along you will compete at such competitions as Battle of The Vans, which as I'm sure you guessed it, wins you a nice rusty old van to hit the road with. Make a bad performance, you won't get paid, and you will lose fans, which will hinder your chances of unlocking the next venue. The best part about World Tour mode is that it can be played alone, or with up to three other people as a full band. This offers an even better experience, and you get a real sense of being in a band as you travel around performing a plethora of tunes. The good thing here is if one of you band members fail a song, you can "save" them by using your star power up to three times. This shows the real co-operative spirit of the game, and a sense of comradre is present.

Game mechanics aren't going to surprise anyone here, hit the coloured notes as required, as they frantically scroll across the fret board. The guitar and bass play beautifully, and the new guitar peripheral adds a sense of realism, both in look and feel. The drums are solid, but make an annoying noise as you are bashing away on them, not too bad if the game is turned up loud (and it should be!) but could be enough to annoy the hell of those rocking out around you. The drums flow well, and regardless of the millions of threads about the foot pedal breaking, it feels firm and safe.

Fret boards are clear and easy to see which is a nice change from the Guitar Hero ones which can be muddles and cause confusion during those hard to play solos. The fret board changes to a blue haze when entering a solo, signaling to use the upper fret buttons on the guitar. It's not necessary, but it's good fun when showing up the other members in your band. The guitar also features a "pickup" switch, which can change the sound of your guitar during these solo segments.

One thing that lets the game down is some minor lag when playing a full 4 player game. Often when a lot is going on at once the frets seem to lag a little, and while it's not a deal breaker, in a game that is based on rhythm, it is detrimental to the title.

The Final Verdict

It may be a year old, but Rock Band is still as relevant today as it was 12 months ago. Featuring an alternative to the sometimes mainstream Guitar Hero track listing, fantastic visuals, decent peripherals and more DLC than you can throw a Snare drum at, Rock Band is worth every beat you will bash out of it

Graphics

8/10

Fret boards are clear and clean, which some players will prefer. The game has gone for a more realistic art style and character models than the guitar hero series, which serves the game well. Camera angles are very reminiscent of some classic music videos. Stages are varied and you never get the "been there done that" kind of feeling.

Audio

9.5/10

Rock Band features a soundtrack that is full of classic tunes, as well as the more underground scene. Featuring bands such as Metallica, Red Hot Chili Peppers, David Bowie and Hole, right down to bands like Interpol, OK Go and Tokyo Monsoon. It has a wide variety of musical styles, and manages to keep a mainstream but not kind of sound to it. It's the little things in Rock Band that sound so great, like if you band is doing particularly well on a song, the crowd can be heard singing along, it's a nice feature which adds to the overall experience.

Value

9.5/10

If you have finished the world tour and are getting a little sick of the track list never fear, Rock Band DLC is here! With over 300 tracks already on Xbox Live for download, and more uploaded every week, it will be pretty hard to grow tired of Rock Band. Also a note worth remembering, all you purchased DLC will work on Rock Band 2 when it is released here!

Overall

8.8/10

submit to digg

1066 Views 19 Votes
Join MyPS3 to vote Add Comment
Gaetano 11/12/2008
Kudos: 9288  Mates: 110
 

Rock Band - Full MyPS3 Game Profile

Rock Band News

Roy Orbison ready to Rock your Band
ICC_06 05/01/2009 4 Comments 13 Votes
Rock Band Confirmed for Australia
Gaetano 22/09/2008 22 Comments 53 Votes

Rock Band Discussions

WTS: Rock Band Drums
ElliotDJ 08/10/2009 1 Posts 41 Views
Rock Band Drums not working???
ElliotDJ 28/09/2009 6 Posts 141 Views
WTS ps3 game
Jimbo_1993 14/09/2009 36 Posts 585 Views

Rock Band Guides

RockBand Set-up Guide
MrPS3 06/01/2009 11 Comments 12 Votes
"Guitar Hero World Tour" VS. "Rock Band"
MrPS3 18/11/2008 14 Comments 23 Votes

Rock Band Reviews

Rock band Review - 10/10
Tekkenfan2 25/02/2008 30 Comments 18 Votes
ROCKBAND - 9/10
Sstick98 31/05/2008 4 Comments 9 Votes
Rock Band Review - 8.8/10
Gaetano 11/12/2008 12 Comments 19 Votes

Rock Band Videos

Comments

Luke4123
Kudos: 25,933
Mates: 1834
Great review heller! Am still deciding whether to get this or GH: WT.
Modern Warfare 2
jason_rhcp
Kudos: 10,434
Mates: 819
Good review Heller

Im justing waiting for Rock Band 2 is australia
Bioshock
Vatoloco
Kudos: 2,557
Mates: 62

Luke4123 said: Great review heller! Am still deciding whether to get this or GH: WT.



Same here Luke

Still a good review though
Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots
mordillo92
Kudos: 3,504
Mates: 72
Nice review. As for Rock Band, I'm staring at it right now as I type, yet I can't play till Chrissy!!
Uncharted Drake's Fortune
heller
Kudos: 3,636
Mates: 95
Thanks for the kind words guys, just trying to help your buying decisions one at a time
Uncharted Drake's Fortune
Dante_10
Kudos: 11,207
Mates: 281
Deffinatly getting this over World Tour.
Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots
heller
Kudos: 3,636
Mates: 95

Dante_10 said: Deffinatly getting this over World Tour.



He has seen the light!
Uncharted Drake's Fortune
mordillo92
Kudos: 3,504
Mates: 72
Woot! I finally got it today for Chrissy! It's so awesome! Drums are admittedly so much more fun than the guitar and I surprsingly also love the mic too, even though I can't sing for s***. Although you really do need to have mates around to have a good time, and that's why tomorrow is the big day! Mad!



Also can't wait for New Years Eve!
Uncharted Drake's Fortune
Kerrby
Kudos: 9,281
Mates: 62
Again, a review under 9/10.
Killzone 2
damex95
Kudos: 178
Mates: 28
Convincing!
Resistance 2
Alex_TXD
Kudos: 14,453
Mates: 110
Nice Review
LittleBigPlanet
joshyboy
Kudos: 486
Mates: 12
i can sing a 90% average in expert songs. It's pretty easy

EDIT: The average for this game would be 9/10 from your scores just to let ya know
 
To participate in this discussion, please log in or register.
MyPS3 User

PS3 Games

MyPS3 Features

Will you be using PSN Cards?
Poll 01/10/2009 109 45
Ninja Gaiden Sigma 2 FAQ
Cheat 22 hours 0 0
WET FAQ
Cheat 22 hours 0 0
Need for Speed SHIFT FAQ
Cheat 22 hours 0 0
PAIN FAQ
Cheat 1 day 0 0
Linger in Shadows FAQ
Cheat 1 day 0 0
Brutal Legend Review
Review 2 days 7 3
Around the Network #15
Blog 2 days 19 0
NBA 2K10 Review
Review 6 days 1 3
Uncharted 2: Among Thieves Review
Review 20/10/2009 10 25
Around the Network #14
Blog 20/10/2009 23 3
Red Dead Redemption Preview
Guide 11/09/2009 9 16
Playstation 3 Slim 120GB Unboxing
Guide 03/09/2009 24 31
PS3 Slim vs PS3 Phat
Guide 01/09/2009 42 32
WWE SmackDown Vs. Raw 2010 Preview
Guide 31/08/2009 31 14
Games to end 2009
Guide 26/08/2009 16 30

PS3 Discussions

PS3 Videos

PS3 Photos

  • Myps3Magazine
    5 7
  • spiranovic's psn card
    9 6
  • Demon's Souls Deluxe Edition Photo 3
    5 4
  • Girls doing it for God?!
    3 4
  • Demon's Souls Deluxe Edition
    3 2
  • box
    0 2

Favourite PS3 Games

MyPS3 Lists

PS3 Games Out This Month

NBA Live 10
10 October 2009 0
Brütal Legend
16 October 2009 10
WWE SmackDown vs. Raw 2010
22 October 2009 1
Fairytale Fights
27 October 2009 0

Recent Comments

Status Updates

ICC_06 wrote a news article - God of War III Demo on District 9 Blu-Ray
saiko added a new video - Greatest freak out ever (ORIGINAL VIDEO)
coeboose3 added a new video - Oghren
coeboose3 added a new video - Sacred Ashes
coeboose3 added a new video - Dragon Age: Origins 30 second TV Commercial